When you choose to publish with PLOS, your research makes an impact. Make your work accessible to all, without restrictions, and accelerate scientific discovery with options like preprints and published peer review that make your work more Open.

PLOS BLOGS DNA Science

Hannah’s 2016: From Curling Toes to Gene Therapy

Eleven-year-old Hannah Sames can still curl her toes, just barely. But time is running out.

If Hannah can move her toes for a few more weeks, until she becomes the fourth child in a clinical trial for gene transfer to treat giant axonal neuropathy (GAN), the disease might halt – and she may even regain function, as mice did.

It’s been an 8-year wait. So Facebook friends call 2016 “Hannah’s year.”

family hannah looking backwardThe first sign that something was amiss in the motor neurons that extend from Hannah’s spinal cord down towards her toes was an odd, hesitant gait as a toddler. A “diagnostic odyssey” finally told Lori and Matt Sames in 2008 that their little girl had an untreatable, ultra-rare condition that’s fatal within two decades. The devastated parents immediately formed Hannah’s Hope Fund, which has nearly entirely funded the research behind the trial at the NIH Clinical Center. Steven Gray, PhD, from the University of North Carolina and his colleagues, developed the protocol.

DNA Science has chronicled Hannah’s journey and the start of the clinical trial nearly a year ago. CBS National News covered the story in October.

singingDuring those years, Hannah’s abilities have waned. At the 5 kilometer Run for Life that HHF holds every August, she’s gone from pushing a doll’s stroller to stay upright, to a walker, to a wheelchair. But Hannah’s spirit hasn’t diminished. She sings the Star Spangled Banner before every race, although this year she had to keep quiet for an hour beforehand so her voice would last through the song. It did, with a little help from Lori near the end.

My daughter and I walked the race with Hannah last August, and just as I admonished Carly for wanting to cheat by cutting across a field, Hannah pointed to it and blurted, “What would happen if we went there?” She led the way, zipping across the field in her motorized wheelchair.

DELIVERING THE GENE
The GAN gene transfer is the first into the spinal cord, and so it could pave the way for treatment for other conditions, such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. The gene behind GAN encodes a protein, gigaxonin, that aligns the girder-like intermediate filaments that fill certain cells.

90270_webThe long axon of a healthy motor neuron is filled with neat, parallel assemblies of filaments, like logs forming rafts in a river. Hannah’s axons in cross section instead resemble logjams. Ultimately, the bloated nerve cells die and muscles no longer receive signals to contract.

In the gene transfer procedure, adeno-associated viruses carry functional gigaxonin genes into the roots of motor neurons in the spinal cord, entering the nuclei and enabling the cells to produce the missing protein. Hannah wasn’t patient #1 because she has two deletion mutations – her cells do not make any gigaxonin at all. Suddenly flooding her system with the protein, foreign to her body, could spike a deadly immune response. Fortunately, standard immunosuppressant drugs prevent such a reaction.

Phase 1 of the clinical trial is assessing safety of one dose in an initial 4 to 6 patients, not more because the loaded viral vectors are expensive and time-consuming to produce. Secondary outcomes peek at efficacy. Is gigaxonin in the spinal fluid? Does a biopsy sample of a peripheral nerve near the thumb have the protein? Has the child improved? What happens to the virus? The kids stay at the Children’s Inn at NIH for 2 months, and are then followed up for 15 years.

Participant #3 and Hannah will receive higher doses than the first patient, Chrissie (a girl), who was treated at the end of May and the second, Gillian, (a boy from Belgium), treated this past fall. Gillian’s mom, Annemie Pasmans, calls the treatment “the golden injection.” Her son and Chrissie received 35 trillion viral vectors, but the next two patients will receive triple that dose. Patient #3 will receive the genes in his spine this month, and Hannah 6 weeks after that – just after her twelfth birthday. Trial details are here.

A RACE AGAINST TIME

Lori and Hannah Sames (Dr. Wendy Josephs)
Lori and Hannah Sames (Dr. Wendy Josephs)

Hannah doesn’t seem as excited about the coming treatment as Lori does, perhaps because she’s so accustomed to medical attention. “She knows Chrissie and Gillian have been injected. She’s not screaming and saying ‘I’m losing function, why is it taking so long?’ She’s 11. She just adapts,” says Lori.

The Sames family has worked tirelessly to maintain Hannah’s mobility. She only uses the motorized wheelchair at school, for example. At home she uses a gait trainer, which is like a walker with a hoist that can bear weight. Lori explains, “we carry her around, and with every transition — kitchen to bathroom, living room to kitchen — we have her stand up and bear weight, and have her move to different surfaces. She doesn’t sit in a chair all day. She bears her weight at least every 2 hours during the day, which has helped her stay stronger. She makes no gigaxonin protein and she’s going to turn 12 and she can walk 10 feet with an adult supporting her under each arm. That’s something!” Hannah is upright in Facebook vacation photos with her parents and two older sisters, Madison and Reagan.

She tires more easily at school now, and often leaves early for physical therapy. But the PT has been vital in preparing Hannah for gene therapy. Lori releases a litany of daily exercises: lung and tongue, fingers and toes. “We fold them all into every day. It’s a full time job.”

Lori tells other parents of the importance of PT. “Keep the toes moving! I put a finger around Hannah’s toes and she curls and squeezes them. If I hadn’t been doing this since she was 3 thanks to what a physical therapist showed me, she wouldn’t still be able to move her toes. The fact that she can do so means that her innervated muscle fibers are still vital. Maybe the ends of the axons haven’t died yet, and they’re just dysfunctional.”

But time is running out. “She is right on the brink! She can barely move her toes. Even two weeks makes a difference. If the IRB (institutional review board) would say she could go 4 weeks after patient #3 rather than 6 weeks, even that would be miraculous. It’s getting right down to the wire,” says this remarkable woman who has served as a nexus in the rare disease community, inspiring many others to channel the angst from a terrible diagnosis into researching and funding treatments.

believe in possibleA self-taught scientist who can dazzle physicians with her knowledge, Lori Sames is first author on a recent paper that urges cooperation between rare disease communities in developing drugs. She’s even thinking past the initial gene therapy to preventing optic nerve degeneration, “riding the coattails” of already successful ocular gene therapies “If patients with GAN lived longer, they’d be blind. Hannah’s optic nerves began lightening by age 7, and we know from preclinical studies that the gene therapy is not going to hit the optic nerve enough to have an impact,” she said.

Lori tries not to dwell on the seven very long years that it took for healthy gigaxonin genes to be gently placed into the first brave child’s spinal cord. She isn’t at liberty to discuss results so far. But it looks like 2016 will indeed be “Hannah’s year.” Said Lori, “It’s finally going to happen!”

(The Forever Fix: Gene Therapy and the Boy Who Saved It, about gene therapy for a form of blindness that is likely to be the first gene therapy approved in the US, includes two chapters about Hannah).

Discussion

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Add your ORCID here. (e.g. 0000-0002-7299-680X)

Back to top